Current Most Popular Old West Rules???

[beerguy]

Fistful of Lead (and now, Reloaded) for ten years or more now.  Easy-to-learn, quick to teach.  For us, it's the right blend of humor, strategy and luck that makes a good game.  We've done three scenarios in one day with six players, five figures/player.  On the plus side (for me, anyway), the lack of bookkeeping and charts cluttering up the game table is wonderful.