Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Login with username, password and session length
News:
Donate to the Lead Adventure Forum to keep it alive!
Home
Help
TinyPortal
Search
Calendar
Gallery
Search
Stats
Donations
Login
Register
Lead Adventure Forum
»
Forum
»
Miniatures Adventure
»
Fantasy Adventures
(Moderators:
white knight
,
Elk101
) »
First (and second!) game of Thud & Blunder
User
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
March 28, 2024, 12:22:38 PM
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Login with username, password and session length
Donate
We Appreciate Your Support
Search
Advanced search
stats
Members
Total Members: 10413
Latest:
FreyaSophie
Stats
Total Posts: 1686477
Total Topics: 118102
Online Today: 857
Online Ever: 2235
(October 29, 2023, 12:32:45 AM)
Users Online
Users: 29
Guests: 662
Total: 691
comet5
spqrdave
manchesterreg
Spinal Tap
Doug ex-em4
mrausten
Idguardnomore2
WarlordFish
manic _miner
The_Beast
randwulf
westwaller
rokurota
v_lazy_dragon
Khusru2
OSHIROmodels
Ash
110thIrishRegiment
Deserter
Silent Invader
Daeothar
YPU
Aethelflaeda was framed
Luigi
Charlie_
DalyDR
Paul Richardson
Recent
Shaguma/Haguma/Koguma hea...
by
rokurota
[
Today
at 12:17:23 PM]
This weeks progress 21st ...
by
Gunner Dunbar
[
Today
at 12:02:33 PM]
(Commercial) New Rules co...
by
soulman
[
Today
at 11:42:55 AM]
Warhammer Renaissance
by
Dr. Zombie
[
Today
at 11:36:34 AM]
[Argad Sengoku] Massacre ...
by
Tom Dulski
[
Today
at 11:18:04 AM]
Wargames Illustrated free...
by
zemjw
[
Today
at 11:15:57 AM]
28mm USMC Vietnam etc
by
Tom Dulski
[
Today
at 11:14:21 AM]
Waterloo in 28mm - My jou...
by
LazyStudent
[
Today
at 11:12:18 AM]
Mean Streets: The Warrior...
by
Tom Dulski
[
Today
at 11:09:33 AM]
(NEW) Post a picture of t...
by
Comstr
[
Today
at 11:00:36 AM]
A thread for all things Q...
by
Malamute
[
Today
at 10:57:07 AM]
Daftest Africa - Pulp All...
by
Digits
[
Today
at 10:56:08 AM]
Revisiting Yellow Ribbon-...
by
OB
[
Today
at 10:55:15 AM]
(SALE) well painted oldha...
by
majorsmith
[
Today
at 10:30:03 AM]
Painting 28mm mounted fig...
by
SteveBurt
[
Today
at 10:24:40 AM]
« previous
next »
Print
Pages:
1
[
2
]
Go Down
Author
Topic: First (and second!) game of Thud & Blunder (Read 4581 times)
D. Brownie
Scientist
Posts: 279
Re: First (and second!) game of Thud & Blunder
«
Reply #15 on:
March 29, 2019, 12:28:20 PM »
Thank you for your kind words!
I should Say that my first criticism was totally unsubstantiated. The core combat system based on a single HP works perfectly and I love It, as the charts to calculate characteristic points.
One important question Is: why should I pay the same for less? For the background flavour... I did it, my Brother not and destroied me 3 times in 3 games, even if the First was more levelled. I don't play to win, but I don't have fun in being heavily underdog every time....
So for example a Natural armour should costs more than a phisical One, 10% more rounding up would be a good compromise.
A zombie that cannot run should cost 1 point less. And so on...
One other balancing thing regards magic. Positive magic Is much more effettive than negative (against enemies). I would take the cure repel spell for my monk, but since you can save from It with a DR (usually 3/4+), I wouldn't wasting time to cast It... On the other hand a spell like Bless Is super useful, since once you cast It Will empower a friend 100% of times...
I would suggest that even in this last case the friend should roll the DR to make the spell effective on him ( modified by the level spell)....
Logged
Craig
Scatterbrained Genius
Posts: 2078
Youth & Talent are no match for Age and Treachery.
Re: First (and second!) game of Thud & Blunder
«
Reply #16 on:
March 29, 2019, 01:05:43 PM »
Hi there,
I shall try and answer a few of your points:
1. All armour costs the same. If your armour is a mail coat or a scaly hide the cost is based upon the armour rating.
2. We did not consider the effect of restricting Zombies to walking only, so a small points reduction would be reasonable.
3. As for spells, have you taken into account the DR penalty for resisting Grade 1 & 2 powers? Also if all of your troops are base Destiny of 3+ or 4+ that is a pretty elite warband.
4. What is a "cure repel" spell?
5. I'm not sure that making a friend have to make a Destiny roll means you have to make two successful Destiny rolls to make one spell work is a good idea. I suggest you try it in a game and see how that works.
Logged
My sincerest contrafibularities
General Lord Craig Arthur Wellesey Cartmell (ret'd)
https://theministryofgentlemanlywarfare.wordpress.com/
D. Brownie
Scientist
Posts: 279
Re: First (and second!) game of Thud & Blunder
«
Reply #17 on:
March 29, 2019, 05:41:20 PM »
Hi,
1. I know It's so, but in this way Is not balanced.
Example: 1 lizardman with scaly armour and a knight with heavy armour are identical with an armour ratio of 13. So same points. But the lizardman has a full Natural armour....
A wizard cast spectral dart against both: the armour of the lizard remains 13, but the knight uses only his physical 7. Then they have to climb a Mountain: the knight has heavy encumbrance, so he can't, no problem for the lizard... The knight cannot use an eventual Speed bonus, while the lizard can. He cannot run and the lizard yes. Consequently the armour cost cannot be based only on Armour Ratio.
2. 1 point here, 1 point there makes on model less in the warband... If you have less you must pay less, even 1 single point....
«
Last Edit: March 29, 2019, 05:47:20 PM by D. Brownie
»
Logged
D. Brownie
Scientist
Posts: 279
Re: First (and second!) game of Thud & Blunder
«
Reply #18 on:
March 29, 2019, 05:51:44 PM »
3. Yes, but repel for ex. Is level 0, so no penalty. If 2/3 of the times my opponent save against It and empowering spells vs Friends work Always, I'll do Always the second.
Logged
D. Brownie
Scientist
Posts: 279
Re: First (and second!) game of Thud & Blunder
«
Reply #19 on:
March 29, 2019, 06:37:09 PM »
4. It's an error, I'm writing with my phone....
5. Two subsequent DR as when you cast for example Curse on your enemy... No more, no less... Sunday I'll try
Obviously are all my opinions, a part from n°4....
Logged
Craig
Scatterbrained Genius
Posts: 2078
Youth & Talent are no match for Age and Treachery.
Re: First (and second!) game of Thud & Blunder
«
Reply #20 on:
March 30, 2019, 07:35:03 AM »
All good points DB and well made
The game was designed with KISS being a key design principle and another being that we encourage players to use it as a toolkit and play around with it.
The points system is optional, and generally there for people who want to play balanced games. We know of a lot of players of our previous games who prefer to work without the points system altogether and they still seem to have lots of fun with the system.
And there is the third design principle, have fun. If that means you want carefully balanced forces do that. If you enjoy narrative adventure more then use the system as a set of guidelines.
We are really looking forwards to seeing what people do with the game, and we expect to be surprised at every turn
Logged
The Bibliophile
Scientist
Posts: 329
Re: First (and second!) game of Thud & Blunder
«
Reply #21 on:
April 25, 2019, 03:04:32 AM »
Another amazingly useful game overview, Hobgoblin. Consistently some of the best in these forums.
Logged
Scrum in Miniature
(my gaming blog):
http://miniaturescrum.blogspot.com
Scrum Con
(my miniatures+RPG convention in Wash, DC):
https://sites.google.com/view/scrum-con/home
Above the Fray Miniatures
(my minis company):
https://sites.google.com/view/abovethefrayminiatures/home
Print
Pages:
1
[
2
]
Go Up
« previous
next »
Lead Adventure Forum
»
Forum
»
Miniatures Adventure
»
Fantasy Adventures
(Moderators:
white knight
,
Elk101
) »
First (and second!) game of Thud & Blunder