Not a bad idea
Can't be any stranger than a dead Zulu at Bosworth anyway...
Meanwhile, I've settled on my counters strategy for Never Mind The Billhooks
As explained somewhere up above, I'm anal about NOT littering my wargames tabletop with plastic chits and printed counters - nicely done as the printed ephemera for NMTBH is.
So in addition to the battlefield casualties as 'Daunted' markers, I'm going to do discarded battlefield debris as 'Disarray' markers.
I'm also doing arrow supply markers (very much as suggested by Lord Callan in the rules), and order tokens.
These will be on steel repair washers, which I use for all my basing - 40mm (for the dead), 25mm, 20mm, and 15mm respectively.
The wonderful side benefit of having built a couple of hundred Perry plastic Wars of the Roses figures, is that I have a vast collection of spare parts, including several hundred heads which will never otherwise be used. So what a great way of using up some of that spare plastic
For the titchy order tokens, I've gone with a single abandoned helmet - these will be murrey-and-blue for York, and blue-and-white for Lancaster (painted helmets were probably a rarity at the time, but hey, nobody knows for sure, so what the hell... ) With white flowers on the York order tokens, and red flowers on the Lancaster ones (Wars of the Roses, see?)
For the 'Disarray' markers, there are many spare parts that can be thrown into the mix to create interesting and varied bases.
On this test piece I've used another sallet helmet, a gauntlet, and a sword in its scabbard. In reality of course, nobody in their right mind would drop an expensive item like a decent sword or helmet (other perhaps, than in a complete panic-stricken rout). But they serve the purpose well enough.
I've pulled out a whole boxful of assorted suitable spare parts - bits of armour cut off redundant bodies or arms (pauldrons will work particularly well for this I think), endless parts of polearms, various pennons and flags, bucklers, cannon balls, broken staves, and so on. Hell, I might even do one with some horse armour
For the arrow supply markers, I've just used a sheaf of Perry arrows (the ones from the Agincourt English set will do just as well as these ones from the WOTR set), and made a small micro-dice shaped recess to take the die that indicates the remaining arrow supply.
Luckily, as a one-time avid collector and player of the Pirates collectible card game, I have thousands of these tiny dice in a whole range of colours. (Although to stay true to my mantra of not littering the tabletop with bits of garish plastic, I'll probably just stick to the muted black ones with white spots).
In all cases, the basic manufacturing process is the same... A small mound of Green Stuff applied directly to the metal base; embed the components, make up the surrounding groundwork with paint/sand/PVA mix, spray the whole thing with primer, paint, add tufts. Simples.
And for scale...