Lead Adventure Forum

Miniatures Adventure => Age of the Big Battalions => Topic started by: ulverston on September 19, 2022, 05:25:31 PM

Title: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: ulverston on September 19, 2022, 05:25:31 PM
Hi Chaps,

Its almost been a quiet year or so for myself hobby wise as work has been eating my time, that is until a few weeks ago when I purchased a 3d resin printer. I have been busy printing out all sorts of bits for my modern collection but then I stumbled upon "the one".

The One in question is a series of STLs made by Felipe Manivel at Madox 3d design. They seem to have character and a pretty comprehensive range

https://www.myminifactory.com/users/Madox%203D%20Design?show=objects&sortBy=date&price=all&page=1&query=

I am not connected to them in any way but wondered what you chaps think?

I have never played a Horse and Musket game though I have owned Black Powder for many years, is this the set you would go with? I was thinking of tinkering and even having 40mm square bases to cut down on the numbers needed and by default increase my gaming table size. 7th Son has lead the way forward with his rules additions to Hail Caesar on Youtube.... has anyone done this?

Lastly I know nothing about this war so I bought the Osprey book to start with, any other essential reading? I appreciate your  thoughts and comments, they will all be useful I am sure. As for the figures I will begin printing in a week or so as even if I never game with them they look amazing.

Thanks in advance


Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: vtsaogames on September 19, 2022, 07:50:27 PM
Take a look at the rules "Loose Files & American Scramble" https://www.wfgamers.org.uk/andy-callans-articles/loose-files-and-american-scramble (https://www.wfgamers.org.uk/andy-callans-articles/loose-files-and-american-scramble)
They give a good overview of the tactical situation. Two other sets of rules are based on them. The more complex; British Grenadier, the simpler: Live Free or Die.

I have yet to try out Live Free or Die but have it in mind down the road.

Plan on fieldiing a good number of Rebel militia. Continentals should be the backbone of the Yanks, but leavened with the lesser breeds. Kings Mountain saw a force of militia vs. an all-Tory force, not a regular in sight save the British CO. Not much cavalry in the northern theaters, a bit more down south.

Battles to look up online: Bunker Hill, Long Island (Brooklyn), White Plains, Trenton, Princeton, Saratoga, Brandywine, Germantown, Monmouth, Camden, Kings Mountain, Cowpens, Guilford Courthouse, Hobkirk's Hill. Encyclopedia Brittanica has a good overview of the war.

I posted this about Washington and his troops last year: http://corlearshookfencibles.blogspot.com/2021/01/george-washingtons-battles-and-rating.html (http://corlearshookfencibles.blogspot.com/2021/01/george-washingtons-battles-and-rating.html)

(https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-Cv0ytayyZp0/X05oqX5pQCI/AAAAAAAADLI/r81eQ1h3nns9iulFB_94r3YDhhjuTlwywCLcBGAsYHQ/s900/ES%2B05.JPG)
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: ulverston on September 19, 2022, 09:15:46 PM
Thank you for your help. Your game looks impressive! I will certainly have a look at the rules you mentioned and your blog.
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: kingsmt on September 20, 2022, 08:32:41 AM
Best advice I can give you is for you to decide early on if you want generic AWI troops or Campaign specific Regiments.

Do you want generic British with yellow, green blue or white facings (the most popular facing colors)?
Or do you want specific Regiments like Highlanders? Loyalists? Provincials?

American units can be blue faced red or brown faced red and you would have them covered.

What I am trying to impress upon you,  is for you to have a plan and to then stick to it.

AWI Uniforms change from year to year. The soldier fighting at Saratoga look nothing like the soldiers at Bunker Hill who look nothing like those at Yorktown.

See where I am going with this?

Before you start buying stuff, do some reading and see what Battles or Campaigns interest you.
The buy a copy of Mollo's Uniforms of the AWI.
It's still the reigning champion!!

Best of luck. Questions?
Check my AWI collection posts on this page to see how it has become an obsession.




Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: Pan Marek on September 20, 2022, 04:56:49 PM
Go to this discussion on "that other page".   I think it provides the best advice available for those just starting in AWI.
http://theminiaturespage.com/boards/msg.mv?id=253118
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: frank xerox on September 20, 2022, 05:56:28 PM
Yup, +1 to that
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: Ceeteegee on September 21, 2022, 07:52:50 PM
Still a page I visit when in need of a little guidance. I also enjoyed the AWI coverage on the Tarleton's Quarter blog which led me to start collecting Loyalist troops. 
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: Tommy20 on September 21, 2022, 08:23:15 PM
That was a really great post from when “that page” actually had useful content.  These days, you have to sift through way too much garbage to find a useful post.

I wonder whatever happened to John the OFM.  He was a curmudgeon to be sure, but was usually a fun read.
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: Pan Marek on September 21, 2022, 09:06:08 PM
Tommy20-
Oh, the OFM still shows up now and again.  Heck, in the link I gave you, he was posting in 2021!  But he's seen less and less.
I myself am one of the many banned for reasons that still baffle me.
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: Codsticker on September 23, 2022, 12:02:38 AM
I am going to follow this thread as I am toying with AWI (love the Fife and Drum Miniatures American Revolution range).
I myself am one of the many banned for reasons that still baffle me.
Same... :?
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: MaleGriffin on September 23, 2022, 01:49:34 AM
Great thread! Thank you for sharing!
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: vtsaogames on September 23, 2022, 02:41:48 AM
Quote
I myself am one of the many banned for reasons that still baffle me.
Likewise.
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: ulverston on September 23, 2022, 11:28:22 AM
Thanks for the help Chaps.... I had no idea that the uniforms changed a lot. I will be playing solo but if they were way out it would bother me no end!
I have the Osprey Revolution book coming and will decide a year or campaign after reading that one. I have been surprised at some of the history having been watching Youtube.... very enlightening.
Mdf carts and houses will be the next items to source, even with printing the figures this is starting to become a larger project than I intended!
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: Ruire on September 23, 2022, 12:58:06 PM
Really your best bet is to pick a year or campaign that seems interesting and work around that. I went with '77 since I'm interested in the Philadelphia campaign, but this also leaves open the possibility of doing Saratoga. Plus, I often use uniforms from '76 and '78 where they're more interesting or there isn't solid information for what a particular regiment was wearing in '77.

You could even think of it in rough periods of time, like 'early war' (1775-'76: Boston, New York, New Jersey), 'mid-war' (1777-'79: Philadelphia, Saratoga, New Jersey, Rhode Island, Sullivan), 'late war' (1780-'83: mostly the South).
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: vtsaogames on September 24, 2022, 02:40:17 AM
I had painted up both sides before a friend noted that none of my British troops were wearing tricorn cocked hats. All had round hats, one side pinned up, or bearskins. So I ordered and painted up a regiment in tricorn cocked hats and trousers. Still not the 1768 warrant. Being a lazy cuss, I painted them from a couple Osprey books so I have a mix of figiures that may not have served together. They still march and fight.

My sole regret: almost all of my figures are 15mm. I purchased 20mm from Frying Pan & Blanket, nice enough figures but out of synch with my other stuff. It's a minor regret. I am not going to redo them in 15mm, unless I have a seizure.
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: kingsmt on September 24, 2022, 05:50:33 AM
As I have advised you previously, pick a Campaign and base your troops around that.

Saratoga British uniforms are unique and never worn anywhere else, so be aware of that.
The '68 Warrant Uniforms were mainly worn at Boston/Concord/Bunker Hill.

As the War progressed, uniforms adapted and changed.
Shorter coats, round hats (with one side turned up) and "overalls', instead of stockings became worn.

The War in the South offers you many more choices. Especially, if you plan to use Cavalry!

Best advice,,,,,,Think before acting (or buying).

What do I want out of this?
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: ulverston on September 25, 2022, 04:43:29 PM
Thanks Kings you are of course correct. Having mentioned this to a mate who rarely games we may even try 6mm first.... its a great period to discover though and very new to me! Nothing seems the same in any year or location!

Thanks again for the help.
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: Old Contemptable on September 30, 2022, 08:44:37 AM
It is a really good period for 28mm. There are so many small to medium size battles that you don't need as many figures as you would with other horse and musket periods. There are quite a number of great figures available. I rather fancy Wargames Foundry, Perry Miniatures, Eureka and Fife and Drum. For someone just starting out, I would recommend building up generic regiments for the Americans. The American uniforms were in a flux throughout the war. So it is hard to pin them down. The previously mentioned TMP thread is a good starting point. I did up some generic blue faced red regiments. They can be filler for just about any year or campaign. From there you can add more specific unit uniforms for the campaign you are interested in.

The only thing that was less known about than American uniforms are American flags. I started out using Betsy Ross stars and stripes flags only to find out later that it never existed. The Betsy Ross stars and stripes flag is a myth. But I am not about to change them. I am just not going to add that flag to any more new regiments. There were probably no starts and stripes flags as we know them today until after the war. The advantage to this is you have a lot a leeway to do as you please with uniforms and flags as long as you stay period correct.

The British, Germans and French flags and uniforms we know a lot about. If you want to do the early war, siege of Boston, Lexington and Concord, then I would go with warrant uniforms. After that the British troops coming from Ireland and Nova Scotia would have the round hats with the black feather in them. They would have roundabouts or cut coats. I wouldn't get too hung up on that. Either one would work. Later when Clinton took over from Howe you would see new units wearing the tri-Croner hat.

The British modified their hats in different ways for the Saratoga and the later Southern Campaign. The Germans and French are going to be wearing their regulation uniforms throughout the war. Very similar to their SYW uniforms. Not all the Germans were Hessians. During the Saratoga Campaign the Germans were all from Brunswick. So there is some uniform variations but you could easily paint up some Hessians and use them as generic Germans. Loyalist units varied and there are some excellent sources in the Osprey Books and Mollo uniform book.

Here is a link to my Flickr page with photos of my AWI games.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/59568506@N02/collections/72157720482428905/



Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: MaleGriffin on September 30, 2022, 04:53:20 PM
Great pics of your troops and games! Thank you for sharing!
Title: Re: American war of Independence any tips?
Post by: Rogerc on September 30, 2022, 06:08:23 PM
Loads of great advice already here.

I second picking a campaign and working on that. You can add bits that allow you to expand out from it.

For rules I am using Live Free or Die which are very good, I am also using Sharp Practice which needs much less figures, if you are building an army from scratch as I did then having a a smaller game to aim for then moving to larger games when you have enough helps with goals and getting maximum gaming from the figures. Have a think about whether the STLs are compatible with other ranges. Kings Mountain, Perry, Foundry and Eureka all work well together would be great if these worked with them too.

If you fancy a look there are some game reports on my blog here:https://gapagnw.blogspot.com/

If you want a really good idea of the differences in uniform the Don Troiani books are wonderful.