This is a very even match-up as far as painting quality goes. I have to base my vote on my totally subjective theme preference again. Great work, in both cases.
Looking at these entries again, I have to add that normally I'd be turned off by shadows in the picture. In this case, however, they're kind of effective, in that the monster is casting a great shadow. And, uh oh, what's the huge shadow on the far right?
