Sikhs won my vote! Although I'm not a big fan of "clones" in such pictures, I think they look better than the pikemen. I really like the uniforms, colors, bases, scenery and the way it all looks together.
The painting style of the pikemen is nice but you're up against some very well painted sikhs, so that's too bad. Like Pil I don't like the base edges and the edge of the paper in the back of the photo is also a small nagging point for me.