Are the rules simple? Oh yes, thank the gaming gods.
Do they move along quickly? Again yes, which is a good thing.
Are they a hoot? For a third time...yes.
I introduced them to our school wargames club. The comments
were very favourable. Several of the pupils are now planning
a Napoleonic clash with figures they will purchase & paint.
You could add more details to the rules, e.g. reduce the firepower
as the unit takes losses, but why bother? other rules (even some from the same stable)
already do that.
Reb&Pats has managed to get my (very dusty) ACW off the shelves & onto the table.
I, for one, am happy with them.