Kite shields or heaters?

[Irregular Wars Nic]

Just starting out with a small force of Anglo-Normans c.1150-1250.

I realise heaters replaced kite shields around this time, but do we have any realistic idea about how long kite shields continued in use?

[Cubs]

From my understanding, from the start of your period the kite shield started getting a flat top and then by the end of your period was largely replaced with the shorter heater shield, at least in Western European. It was doubtless a gradual progression with various warlords making the change as they saw fit. I think the kite shield was used for longer in the Levant and Byzantium.

[rampantlion]

I would say that the closer to 1250 that most would be heater shields.  For 1150 I think a mix of kite shields and elongated heater shields (kite shield with top cut off flat basically in shape).  I am not an arms expert, but that is what I have done for my figures in this time period.

[Breazer]

My advice would really be go with what you think looks best. In the end I doubt anyone really would contest it.

[Irregular Wars Nic]

Thanks for the advice gents.

Would the Fireforge Medieval foot sergeants work for this period? They seem to have broad brimmed salets in among the helmets which I always consider more 100 years war...

[Breazer]

Its difficult to find good miniatures for this time period. I use the fireforge ones but I kitbash everywhere i can. If you do go for fireforge i'd advice to at least sculpt your own necks on the miniatures with a bit of greenstuff.. it makes them look a lot more like humans that way.

some of the kettles and the flattops work I think.