Donate to the Lead Adventure Forum to keep it alive!
Gothic Horror would work for that.I know many people of issues with the rulebook but I find it easy to follow and use.
What don’t you like about Fistful of Lead?We use The core rules which give you all the details you need to low tech weapons and armour. Tales of Horror gives you stats for the supernatural creatures.Here is an AAR doing the above with Medieval knights Vs Werewolves.http://leadadventureforum.com/index.php?topic=113931.0I can’t think of anything else better suited.
Think of the two books (core and ToH) as interchangeable, you can use traits and rules from each bOok to customise your game. Once you’re familiar with the core mechanics and how teams are created it’s easy to pull traits From each book to create an individual team. That’s the point of the supplements to the core rules, they extend the games into specific genres.In our game the knight and retainers had the armour trait and medieval weapons from the core set. We used the holy/blessed/silver weapons from the ToH set.There are several good traits like devout and word of god that would work for a knight or monk in ToH.