Atually the rules are cool, however too confusing for a twelve year old, I think. They even are a challenge for myself and sometimes hard to master, but I was convinced after a couple of games. I had played Battlefleet Gothic before and X-Wing of course. I really like it though, but I admit that it's a strategic approach there that isn't necessarily appealing to everyone. one could hardly cope on a tactical basis if circumstances appear that one isn't prepared for. I like that, because such is life and even more a real battle. All good plans are scrap once you face the enemy...