I've been following your thread with a lot of interest, as I've been toying with this idea for years. The (for me and my collection) new scale has kept me back so far though.
One of the first miniature wargames I ever played (if not THE first), was Classic BatleTech (before it was even called Classic
). I had the Battletech Compendium, a Revell Warhammer/Excalibur/Tomahawk model and some plastic soldiers. So me and a school buddy played a CityTech scenario on a map drawn on a large sheet of paper (A2 size).
He played the infantry and got completey annihilated. I especially enjoyed the moment I walked my Mech through a low building to get to some soldiers hiding in there.
Of course the roles were reversed next and I got my forces reduced to pink mist as well, but it was great, great fun.
So your idea of using larger scale mechs appeals to me a lot.
You mention using kits of different scales, and also Gashapon mechs. But to my eye, only going by Ebay and other internet pictures, those Gashapon are pretty small. Since you're working in N-scale, most Mechs should size up to approximately 7 centimeters, if we go with an average height of 10 or so meters. So do they match up?
I was thinking of going 15mm / 1/100 myself, making everything even larger, because, well, with Mechs, larger is always better. (My life's ambition would of course be fully functional Mechs in 1/1 scale
). But I suppose in this scale, the Gashapons are out of the question.
Also, there's quite a discrepancy in scale, even within ranges of the same manufacturer. I've got a Quadluun Rau in 1/144, which I've converted to contain a 28mm sized cockpit, and it's still huge! Imagine its comparative size when matched with other 1/144 scaled stuff
(Ok; I know Zentraedi are supposed to be 10 meters tall themselves, but come on...)
So I think cherrypicking Mechs to match their BattleTech sizes might be best, from a range of scales like 1/200, 1/144, 1/100 and maybe even 1/76. But finding the actual sizes of the kits online is right chore at times. You'd say at least height would be stated, but only the box sizes are usually given (plus the fictional height of the Mech). So it's pretty hard to gauge the size of the kit you're looking at.
The fact they're usually photographed against a blank background does not help either.
But for now, I'll round off my ramblings with a list of questions that popped up reading your thread:
- How do you do the size matching thing? Or do you simply end up with a lot of off-sized Mechs?
- Where's the Locust from? Not-anthropomorphic Mechs are not the easiest to find (exception is the Marauder/Glaug of course
).
- How do the original metal Battletech infantry scale? Are they acceptable as 15mm, or are they smaller?
- How do the Clix infantry and vehicles scale? are they simply scaled to match their bases, or is there a standardisation? And what scale would that be? (This in regard to Elementals...)
- Have you considered playing without a hex-grid? It's about the only aspect of the game I'm not too fond of; the grid detracts from the overall terrain look IMHO...
And finally; please keep going; your project is very inspirational!