I agree with Curtis, just have a go. I've mucked about with casting pewter in moulds made from silicone caulking out of a tube (for windows, bathrooms etc from the hardware store) and from simple moulds made of MDF not unlike in this instructable (
http://www.instructables.com/id/Simple-Pewter-casting/#intro).
I used damaged pewter mugs from the opp-shop melted down in a coffee pot on an electric hotplate. I tried making barrels (with the silicone moulds) and name badges (unrelated to the hobby) with the MDF moulds, with reasonable success. My main problem was air bubbles. The moulds do deteriorate over time, the MDF scorches, and in my case I damaged it because the pewter got stuck, and I found the silicone got a bit burned and sticky after a few goes. Miscasts can be thrown back in the pot to try again, and since bases are large and flat without many fiddly bits you shouldn't have too much trouble getting the metal where it needs to go.
Using these materials I'm sure isn't as good as the proper casting kit, but it's a lot cheaper; caulk here is about $6 a tube, the pewter mugs were $2 each, I also got the hotplate and coffee pot second hand as well, if memory serves I think the hotplate was $8 and the coffee pot would have only been $1-$2. MDF I have lying around. Unfortunately I did this some time ago and don't have any pics for you, but I reccommend you give it a go. Worst that can happen is it doesn't work satisfactorily, if it does though make sure to take piccies for us!