I just watched that movie last week when we had a snow day! Maybe the settler who wouldn't quit was the tough as nails old granny...ha, ha!
Anyway, you are right the Q4 Leaders are not the best bet. In almost all convention games, I use:
Leaders, Q3 C3
Rank & File, Q4 C2
That way, the followers are never easier to activate than their leader...they are the same, at best.
Clever idea for a scenario. I agree that letting the Indians come in on the short sides would make it more gripping. But hey! Any special kind of scenario like this needs playtesting. Nothing wrong with that...I am always tweaking and revising my scenarios.
Can I link your blog AAR on our Battle Reports page?
And I have to say, I absolutely love that you are sowing the next crop/generation of gamers with our rules! Every time one of your kids enjoys a game, it makes every minute I spent developing, writing, and playtesting these rules worth gold!!!
Mike Demana
www.worldwidemike.com