I don't think any of Calmdown's posts have been negative concerning Frostgrave. The simple truth is that no game is perfect, its just a matter of whether the niggles make it worth playing anyway or house ruling.
The fact that it is the latter is very positive in my eyes.
Calmdown's articles combined with a good review on the DeltaVector blog convinced me to buy a copy (its in the post somewhere). Without both these sources I would never have bought the game because of who the publisher is.
I look forward to reading the book when the package arrives on my doorstep, tomorrow?