What's your favorite rules set for regimental level ACW?

[Dukewilliam]

As the title states: what's your favorite rules set for playing regimental level ACW games? I used to have F&F but found it too rules intense for the outcomes. I'd like something that plays relatively fast, without too many modifiers and too many mnemonic devices cluttering up the battlefield. I hate when every unit has dice, pipe cleaners, etc... following them around, though it is not necessarily a deal breaker if the rules are good enough.

Am I asking too much?

Your thoughts please. What's your favorite rules set?

Patiently,
Steve

[Old Contemptable]

We use "Mr. Lincoln's War" they are simple and gives a good game.

https://onmilitarymatters.com/product/1-72720

Some pics of our MLW games.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/59568506@N02/collections/72157720410732823/

[FifteensAway]

Used to be Johnny Reb 2 but that became tedious, tried F&F and way too wonky.  Settled on Rank and File, more the basic version than the ACW version - easy to learn, fast to play, gets to results, and can conclude a fairly good sized game in a couple of hours.  And lends well to multi-player games.

Friends who love F&F play maybe two or three turns in all day slogs where I could run a complete ACW multi-division game, clear the table and set up and AWI game and run a good portion of it before they can finish a game without getting anywhere near a conclusion.  Don't know why it has such die hard adherents - but it does have them.

For Rank and File the most oft heard complaint is it doesn't allow command radius type stuff - a fair observation but not too hard to cobble something on.  The rules are highly flexible and easily adjusted without breaking them.  Or you can just use the ACW addition which does have it.

[Old Contemptable]

We played JR2 for years, then tried JR3. We were tired of the unusual basing scheme and the charges that were too drawn out. It got old. Every game was like you had never played before. Then we switch to MLW and never looked back. Granted we made our own modifications to our taste.

[Old Contemptable]

We use 15mm because of the size of games we like to play. Big battles or parts of big battles. 28mm has too much of a footprint which limits the size of games you can do.

[Old Contemptable]

If you want to get rid of clutter then MLW might not be for you. Like JR it requires the use of order markers and we use pipe cleaners. I hate clutter too, but I don't know how you get around that.

[Redshank]

Bonnie Blue Flag by Kevin Calder came out in 2017 and is aimed at regimental level ACW. I have never played but there are some reviews knocking around online.

The basic idea seems to be you roll against a unit's percentile score when the unit is tested, e.g. it comes under fire. If you fail the throw, the unit acquires "attrition" and can retreat or rout. The rules are short - only about 20 well-spaced B5 pages (then examples, scenarios etc.). You could probably easily run it off the QRS. In case it is any use as a reference, it reminds me a lot of the simple percentile-based rules in Donald Featherstone's Lost Tales.

The reviews and AARs suggest it is fast playing. There are no particular basing requirements, although there are suggestions. In terms of clutter, the author recommends placing a tiny d6 next to each unit to record its attrition level, but you could keep a separate record card instead I suppose.

Like I say, I've never tried it, but I thought I would throw it into the mix.

[Golgotha]

Rank and File is a good call - provides a fun game. Has anyone tried "They Couldn’t Hit an Elephant" - Too Fat Lardies? or for that matter "Battle Cry"?

Certainly, still looking for a set of rules I can settle on... I probably have a few other sets than those suggested below but would need to look - I do remember playing one set which I vowed to never try again but can't recall the name.

ACW Rules I have tried include,, note many of these would not fulfill the regimental distinction:

Also see here for a bigger version of the below: https://frictionbmcminiatures.blogspot.com/search/label/ACW

[Frostie]

Black Powder with Glory Hallelujah supliment

[Golgotha]

That is a great find Vexillia I see they have a number of free rules available and also a channel on Youtube see: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCLuqlmCWWVODRQUEvMHb7XA/videos

[SteveBurt]

Longstreet is very good, and plays fast. Works well for historical battles too

[Golgotha]

Longstreet sounds interesting. Some interesting ideas here https://boardgamegeek.com/thread/2738438/american-civil-war-game-suggestions

[bluewillow]

I am a Jonny Reb 3 fan, although the charge sequence is over complex. I really like the seesawing effect the rules produce and I feel they reproduce an ACW battle very well.

I have also used Fire and Fury Regimental and Black powder.

cheers
Matt

[CapnJim]

My gaming group really likes Gettysburg Soldiers.  Simple, fun-to-play, and markers are really needed to play the game.

[Dukewilliam]

Thanks men, I appreciate the help.

I actually own Rank and File and the ACW supplement and have ordered Mr. Lincoln's War; so we will see how they compare.

Steve