This was a tough one. I LOVE the set-up for Kansas 1851 - the buildings are a great backdrop, the painting is crisp, and the bases are really nicely done. However, the detail in Moriarty's gang tips the balance in the end - the faces (the eyes!), the plaid pants, the scar and the stubble. So, even though I live in Kansas, I had to go for dastardly Moriarty, but it was a very, very close one to call.