I've gotten some great help from these forums, so I thought I'd share what I've been working on, for others to use.
My original plan was to purchase some official SA minis after buying terrain and the books. However, about halfway through the process, I found myself a little tight in the cash department. So, I decided I'd have to settle for making my own paper minis, for now.
PDF download: (looks lo-rez but isn't when you download)
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B9TdbsP3Ay4qVkpJaG1yT0lGa00/editSince I didn't label the actual document, I'll just list the units. The actual pdf is also brighter.
Caveman, Cultist, High Priest(ess), Cult Leader, Degenerate, Henchman, Kindred, Mad Scientist
Maniac, Tribal Elder, Suicidal Cultist, Shaman, Witch, Ghoul, Ghoul King, Fishman
Ancient Warrior, Deep One, Mummy, Tcho-tcho, Serpentman, Night-gaunt, Deep One Hybrid
Hound of Tindalos, Werewolf, Familiar, Missing Link
(Starting top-left) Deadly Spawn, Zombie Dog, Formless Thing, (middle-right) Creeper Vines, Poltergeist
Scrawny One, Winged Horror, Venus Flytrap, Giant Ape, (middle-right) Giant Snake, Velociraptor, Restless Spirit, (next row) Giant Spider, Giant Insect
(top-left) Banshee, Mojo, Blasphemous Construct, Zombie, Dark Puppeteer, Conglomerate, (bottom-left) Fire Daemon, Night Stalker, (middle-bottom) Giant Vermin
(top-middle) The Horror, Godling, (bottom-left) Servitor, (bottom-right) Shambler
(top-left) Mushroom Forest, Pterodactyl, (top-middle) Swarm, (middle-right) Triceratops, Tyrannosaurus, (bottom-left) Sabertooth Tiger
UPDATE: I also made a sheet of Threshold agents and two correctly-sized Scenes of horror!
Full-rez Download: https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B9TdbsP3Ay4qSXlWTnZvd3JPeTQ/edit