A thought experiment - on AMT AT-ATs, Rogue One AT-ACTs and beyond

[Vanvlak]

In the Rogue One Ultimate Visual Guide it says the AT-ACT (All Terrain - Armoured Cargo Transport) is even larger than the AT-AT. Now when I saw the film I hadn't even realised they weren't AT-ATs, but that's not the point here. I have an AMT AT-AT, and it's out of scale (too big) for X-Wing (yes, I know X-Wing usually happens in space, which isn't where AT-ATs are found usually). I'm a bit of a stickler for scale, although not an extremist. So how bad would it be if I used my AMT AT-AT with X-Wing models?
I know I could ignore the scale as a detail here, or just pretend it's a bigger model - but is it very bad of me? I still have a niggling feeling about it, and want to get rid of it....

[rumacara]

Enjoy...

https://www.shapeways.com/shops/mel_miniatures?s=0

[The_Beast]

...
- but is it very bad of me? I still have a niggling feeling about it, and want to get rid of it....

I think I only saw it on TMP, but there's at least one fellow using X-Wing ships in ground attack mode, cobbled with homemade rules, and it was AWESOME!

Bad? Absolutely BADD ASSSS! 

Doug

[Elbows]

Beasts of War did a ground attack X-Wing game based around an Endor styled jungle etc. (ie. the fighters had to actually be cognizant of large trees, etc.)

[Vanvlak]

Enjoy...

https://www.shapeways.com/shops/mel_miniatures?s=0

Argh! 
This is going to hurt, methinks....

[Vanvlak]

I think I only saw it on TMP, but there's at least one fellow using X-Wing ships in ground attack mode, cobbled with homemade rules, and it was AWESOME!

Bad? Absolutely BADD ASSSS! 

Doug

I think I saw that somewhere, can't find it again.

[Vanvlak]

Beasts of War did a ground attack X-Wing game based around an Endor styled jungle etc. (ie. the fighters had to actually be cognizant of large trees, etc.)

I'll look for it...thanks.

[Grimmnar]

Enjoy...

https://www.shapeways.com/shops/mel_miniatures?s=0

That Mel has been a busy boy for some time now.

Grimm

[AKULA]

That Mel has been a busy boy for some time now.

Grimm

Indeed. Some of his armada ships even fit in with my 1/2256 project.

 

[Steam Flunky]

Found the x-wing on Endor from Beasts of war - http://www.beastsofwar.com/star-wars/star-wars-day-beasts-war/
Fantastic looking game.