A spoiler on our next scenario...
Rocky pulled two red herrings in a row in the final flight game, denying him any chance of victory. (See story above)
In the Soerabaja Manhunt, he continued this trend, pulling 5 (by one count 6) straight red herrings. This resulted in massive frustration! In the end, we gave him the plot point.
Not sure when that AAR will hit the streets, but it is in the works.