I thank you on behalf of Steve whose collection this is.
It would be unwise of me to comment on playability or comparison of General at Sea having not played them myself, but I have a comment from Steve, whose AAR’s I have reported on and who is a much more reliable source, commenting as I have quoted here on the rules and the next game he is planning to portray using them;
“. . the collection was designed to fight the largest battles of the 2nd ADW using the General at Sea scale of one stand representing 3 - 4 ships. I have slightly more than is needed for The Four Days Fight and St James’ Day Fight, and just enough Dutch for Lowestoft.
I am setting up the next game based on the opening moves of Lowestoft where the White Squadron under Sir Christopher Myngs competed with the Dutch for the weather gauge. He won on that occasion but failed in similar circumstances at the beginning of day four of the Four Days Fight and was mortally wounded. I thought it would be interesting to have a line of battle engagement next.”
I hope that provides a bit more insight.
Cheers
JJ