I'd been waiting for the Crocodile Games minotaurs but now I'm looking at them painted in their store I'm not so sure about them - I may still get them though. I have a very specific idea of how minotaurs should look and although we're spoilt for choice on minotaur minis from a host of manufacturers there isn't really one which hits the nail on the head for me. I think I prefer the overall design of the Scibor and Avatar's of War minotaurs but they have hooves!
I think they should have human feet, not hooves - I can think of maybe two or three manufacturers who produce them with humanoid feet including the newly released Crocodile Games ones, most designers seem to prefer hooves, even in 2d art or video game models hooves appear to be the standard.
Bodywise I think they should have a stocky, muscular build, perhaps with a bit of a belly.
Also they need a head and horns which are proportionate - many minotaur miniatures seem to have heads and/or horns which are way to large or small. It also seems to be quite a skill to get the horns to look right in such a way that they appear to be growing out of the skull rather than just stuck on.
Weird looking faces or overall cartooniness also seems to be a common problem. I'm not too bothered about oversized weapons as these can always be swapped out.