Would prefer the commando with less clutter.
Especially the gun and helmet. They don't make sense - how did it attach them with those webbed hands? Why has it collected them - not for use, water would do the gun no good - and as trophies, why lug around something large and cumbersome? If he's going to take a hat as a trophy why not just take the head that was inside it? Probably in a small net bag, like scuba divers use.
To be fair, my main issue with the gun and helmet is that it limits the use of the figure. Without them I could use the figure for other settings, VSF, 1920s, SF, etc. but with them it's just 1940s or 1950s. For me, a multi-purpose figure is a better option in the current financial state of play.