Somewhat late to this party...
What I am thinking however is that I've equipped the soldiers with WW2 webbing but have armed them with a 1959 rifle. Hmm.. now I was after a generic B movie look but I don't want them to look too 'wrong'. Do you think its a passable sin or would this webbing and an M14 never ever be seen together under any circumstances?
Highly doubtful. Like having a BREN section equipped with Pattern '08 pouches or Slade-Wallace.
Carrying the magazine for the M-14 would be a pain with standard US WW2 webbing, unless you had the BAR magazine holders.
Better off modelling the M-1956 equipment IMO.
This. The M-14 is a magazine fed rifle. We used stripper clips & guides to load magazines, not the rifle. The only US webbing pre-M56 that works for M-14 magazines are BAR belts, and the 30-cal carbine 4 30 round pouches, which hold ONE M-14, nothing else standard fits. You could load your Garand belt with 7.62 stripper clips, but why would you?
To be honest if you wanted generic '50s troops you probably would have been better off with M1 Garands. The M-14 took quite a while to roll out as did the webbing. There are photos of National Guard soldiers at Fort Drum, New York in 1970 still wearing WW2 webbing, albeit equipped with WW2 weapons.
In the fall semester of 1972 our college ROTC arms room had brand new M-14s, '03 Springfields, with 16" bayonets, for the drill team, 2 BARS, & and one M1919A4 LMG. The M-14s replaced the last of the Garands that left that spring, & the rest of WWII stuff departed before I could wring 'em out. Web gear issued with the M-14s was M-56, what was designed for it, already out of Regular Army service, replaced by nylon & soon ALICE gear. We didn't have any M1 carbines though, gthey were probably all out working for a living.
I was always taught that if you're going to do something, do it properly. Seriously when that giant Tarantula is wading through your army men you don't want some tosser pointing out that they have the wrong rifles for 1955.
Seriously, that's just what tossers, button counters & stitchnazilike me
LIVE for!!
Not being able to giggle, tee-hee, belittle or revile your opponents toys just sucks the life out of it for me...
Matching the webbing to the weapon is a smart decision, as is seeking crossover appeal.
Personally I'd love to see more minis with .30 cal carbines, M1, M1A1 & M2.

looks men


Bayonet lug & the original
"banana clip" makes it post-WWII, & looks mean!! The indistinguishable M2 config is full auto capable.
M1 & M2 Carbines are the original "Poor Man's
'Assault Rifle' " Every theatre in WWII, every US conflict through Viet Nam, every revolution or banana war since 1943 on one side, or the other or both, beloved of cops n'crooks, prison guards & partisans, Bugsy Siegel was killed by one & Patty Hurst used one to rob banks. These lil' rascals are ubiquitous, except behind the Iron Curtain. Every continent, every conflict, and
WAY over-represented in Hollywood '40s through to the '80s. M1 carbines pop up in all the oddest places!!
A GI with one is useful most anywhere, anytime, ditto suitably garbed civvies in any post-WWI scenario. With a 30 round banana mag & a stock pouch with 2 15s you
almost don't even need webgear!!
Yeah, I'm a fan...
& would cheerfully snap up minis so armed, even though my focus is earlier.
& for those of you who must metrify, think 7.62x33, just as German & Austrian Border Guards did until quite recently...
Valerik
War Baby fan from way, way back