Round 3 - The Brave Companions vs. Into the Dungeon

[Prof.Witchheimer]

[Dolmot]

Bah, you should have paired 'Into the Dungeon' with 'In the Dungeon'. You don't get a chance like that too often.

[Steam Flunky]

Oh man. If this is not the most difficult decision of the year.
Battle of the giants.

[Prof.Witchheimer]

Bah, you should have paired 'Into the Dungeon' with 'In the Dungeon'. You don't get a chance like that too often.

I really would love to but that's not my decision, you know, the Swiss System.

[TheBlackCrane]

Wow. Just, wow.
How are we supposed to decide between these?!

[Captain Blood]

Gah! The Swiss System is my undoing. Michael, had I figured on meeting you this early in proceedings, I would have prepared something suitably dioramic to put me in with a chance! That is a stunning entry my friend. Congratulations 

[McMordain]

 
So should it be a coin toss or rolling a dice?
Both entries are amazing.

[Uncle Mike]

Both fantastic! Although that scenery really is fantastic! 

[Lt. Hazel]

Wow. Great entries, but I think the scenery makes the difference.

[Charlie_]

I really wanted to vote for Captain Blood, because I much prefer the subject matter and miniatures....

But I gotta admit, that scenery deserves the vote!

[DivisMal]

Tough choice. My vote went to Captain Blood, because I really loved the little details, like the eyes of the horses.

That dungeon however is really nicely built, too!

[Orctrader]

Both brilliant. 

[thebinmann]

WOW

[Mancha]

I am so not a fan of fantasy that when fantasy goes up against any other theme, I'll usually choose the other entry.  And when the other entry is from Captain Blood, this is usually an even easier system.  In this case, however, it wasn't so much the dungeon theme that earned my appreciation in the Admiral's entry, but rather the big open expanse of nothing in the Captain's entry that forced me to take a closer look at his opponent's entry.  I gotta love the bar wench, who was apparently picked up at the Three Dragons by an admiring group of adventurers and given a sword.

[S44lade]

Both truly superb - extremely tough decision