Shield dilemna - opinions sought

[Svennn]

Did a bit more on my Tang Chinese. The shields supplied are correct for the period but I have an illustration with a larger design. Also the picture shows the shield resting on the floor which I think is very plausible for a guard stance. I made the alternative from plasticard and greenstuff (should have spent longer on it) and now am undecided which to use.


Svennn

[Lowtardog]

Is the middle one the original?

[Malamute]

For a guard stance I like the resting on the floor look.

 The last shield is presumably your home made one and its a nice colourful design.

How many you are going to need ?

 Weigh up the time to make your own shields with an attractive design against the simplicity but ease of painting the plain one.

Tough call....

[Lowtardog]

Tough call at Malamute says, could you rest the smaller one just under his left hand as if he is almost leaning on it?