Lighten up. 
It always has to boil down to an 'I hate GW' argument...
What I meant by my statement is that, yes they are meant to be historical, but perhaps they have been done to also fit into the fantasy purpose based on the popularity of the army. Nothing wrong with that.
I was also basing my comments on what others here have said; that the miniatures are wielding large weapons, way beyond what would be historically accurate.
However, I REALLY don't want this to become an I hate GW message/topic.
Cool minis, they *COULD* be used for GW's Warhammer Fantasy Battles (as they have rather large swords), but *more likely* as historical Landschneckts.