so has anyone shed a tear yet? Or is it not that amazing?
Eyes misted up in the opening crawl and never really recovered, but I'm a nostalgic and sentimental old sap.

Apart from that I concur with previous reviewers in the thread. Some shortcomings, but 100% enjoyable. I'd rank it higher than ROTJ, for now. That might change on repeat viewings - but it's a damn good Star Wars film.
If I should complain about anything, it would be the explanatory emphasis used at times. "What do they look like?" *object appears on screen, which is the punch line of the gag* "Like that!" <- unnecessary foolproofing which spoils the moment a bit. It's like parents referring to their kid as "our son" instead of "Steve". It was a bit blunt at times, spelling things out.